Posted by:
Nontheist for Reason
(
)
Date: January 01, 2021 11:46PM
I agree with what Summer said:
“I always recommend that people coming from the high-control Mormon faith look at the more moderate mainstream churches. Take a look at the Episcopal church, the ELCA Lutherans, the UMC Methodists, the PCUSA Presbyterians, and the United Church of Christ.”
I found these churches she mentioned viable options after leaving Mormonism. As for the other types of churches, when I visited the more Fundamentalists churches I always tried to get them to narrow down their source tradition, and if it was Calvinism I high tailed it out of there. If they taught hell fire torture for thought crimes, I was gone. I think it's emotional child abuse to teach that to kids.
I visited the Unitarian Universalist church a few times and generally liked the vibe but where I live there is not one nearby. But many exmo's have found it a viable option.
When I left Mormonism I basically became a studious hermit except for close friends, family, and an atheist and agnostic meetup group I attended for years. I went church shopping recently and was turned off by all the Fundamentalist type churches in my area.
One day I will try out a "liberal" Jewish synagogue (I want nothing to do with the orthodox kind) which is an option for me, as it seems to have things I did like in Mormonism without the cultism. And Jesus was Jewish; so if I really wanted to do what Jesus would do, wouldn't I become a Jew?
After leaving Mormonism I applied the same rigorous skepticism I did toward Mormonism toward Christianity and found it even more problematic than Mormonism. Just one example, read the work of scholar Paul Middleton on the first Christians who were voluntary martyrs. Basically first century Pauline Christianity was initially a religious-suicide-cult (think Heaven's Gate without the UFOs). Take up your cross in Mark was about actually carrying your cross to martyrdom, and Paul constantly said things like "to die is gain," and right there in 1 Corinthians 13 you have Paul speaking favorably about someone voluntarily getting burned to death "IF" it is done in agape love of course. Anyway, once your eyes are open to this earth-life-rejecting death cult emphasis, it is hard not to see it all over the NT. It's why the Jesus character says its most ideal if able to become a eunuch, and to sell your possessions, and Paul encourages celibacy in 1 Cor. 7; as the goal was not buying a home and retirement planning and building a better world on earth, but rejecting the "demon infested" earth and human passions and instead the goal was getting yourself killed as a martyr so you could escape your adamic body and "sprout" a new Jesus genus (a spirit body) that would basically hatch out of your corpse at the arrival of the Messiah (see 1 Corinthians 15 and Frank Viola's book From Eternity to Here: Rediscovering the Ageless Purpose of God).
BUT, but! ... we live in a Christian culture, and Americans have reinterpreted the NT to make it say things it does not say, like the "prosperity gospel" despite the NT actually being about anti-money pro communistic utopianism awaiting the Jehovian end-times. So why not make it say whatever you want when everyone else is. So these are the brands of Christianity that I recommend as an "thinking" exmormon:
The types of Christianity that I promote and endorse are:
Petersonian Christianity: Dr. Jordan Peterson combines a wide variety of philosophies and psychologies into one, as diverse as Nietzsche and Carl Jung.
Sean McCraney's ChristiAnarchy at
https://hotm.faith/Joshua Jipp's book Saved by Faith and Hospitality
Jonathan Mitchell’s New Testament translation and articles:
https://www.jonathanmitchellnewtestament.com/jonathan-s-recommendations/general-christianity-theology/David Bentley Hart's book That All May Be Saved
The Unvarnished New Testament by Andy Gaus (This is the best translation I have found. It allows you to read it "raw" without all the post-Constantine Augustinian theological gloss)
Marcus Borg's book Speaking Christian and The Heart of Christianity
John Spong's book Rescuing the Bible from Fundamentalism and his other books