Posted by:
amos
(
)
Date: January 15, 2011 03:16PM
The premise of the need for a sealing is that we don't come sealed as is. Not even by birth? The D&C says that the need for a sealing is because all man-made contracts have an end when we die, and that therefore you're no longer married to your spouse when you die because it was only man-made civil authority. OK. But what about natural born children? What's the rationale in the Mormon heaven for splitting parents from children? You obviously don't have to be married to have children, you need no authority or permission. It's just a built-in power of nature.
As a TBM I just took it for granted, of course, if we're not sealed then we can't be a family. But WTF??? Why not? I never pondered the concept that the default state is "sealed" naturally, and you'd need some interference to reach the Mormon default state of unsealed.
Preexistence always seemed like a perfectly harmless and benign concept, but now I see it as a major loophole. You can sail ships through it. All kinds of logic follows if we had a preexistence. You can say, like I said, that well we weren't arranged into biological families there, and thus biological families aren't the default condition (an AMAZING leap now that I think about it). Then, you've got your valiance bull shit, where you can speculate that consequences have carried over into mortality from unseen events, like why it's fair that black skin and other "curses" follow the children of them that hate God unto the third and fourth generation.
It's not just a scientific leap that we came from a previous dimension, it's a MORAL leap too, because then we start blaming people for shit they must have done there to cause their curses here. It's a VERY inequitable cop out.
So, according to this paradigm, your naturally born child is only tentatively yours, per some deal in the preexistence, and when life's over, deal's off, you didn't get sealed. Well, I know, the church has this huge proxy sealing alibi, OK. My point is that "heaven" would need a reason to separate you, not a reason to unite you.