Posted by:
anonlady
(
)
Date: January 13, 2014 08:43AM
MovingOn, you described a classic case of abusive behavior. Get a copy of Lundy Bancroft's "Why Does He Do That? Inside the Minds of Angry, Controlling Men." Bancroft, a counselor and therapist who spent 20 years working with abusive husbands, explains in detail how abusive, affluent men systematically turn their children, extended family, counselors, therapists, and the justice system against their ex-wives, why they do it, and how to fight back (to the extent such is possible).
Also get a copy of Dr. Patricia Evans' book, "The Verbally Abusive Relationship." ASAP.
As for Wallerstein, she studied a very small sample group in the 1960s and 1970s, using flawed methodology and collecting only anecdotal data. The biggest problem, though, is that her subjects were handpicked from a group of individuals who had been referred to her clinic because they were already severely troubled. There was no control group, no comparison, and no study of non-troubled subjects. From that group, Wallerstein drew conclusions about the population at large and generalized that all divorce irreparably harms the children. Here are some articles that explain:
http://www.divorceinfo.com/judithwallerstein.htmhttp://www.wayneandtamara.com/judithwallerstein.htmhttp://books.google.com/books?id=SsqfOrhd1u0C&pg=PA171&lpg=PA171&dq=Wallerstein+study+flawed&source=bl&ots=okKHeSIn a 1989 interview, Wallerstein said that she would never advise parents to stay together merely "for the sake of the children" -- even though she'd made millions from her book which said exactly that!
IMHO, our culture forgets that until very recently, intact two-parent nuclear families were NOT the way most people grew up. Many cultures had other systems. Even in Western patriarchal societies, death often deprived children of one or both parents (Ex: Europe during the Black Plague) -- not to mention maternal death during or shortly after childbirth, men getting killed due to war, etc. Yes, death is "different" than divorce for children -- and arguably worse.
In any case, guilting the parent whose spouse dumped them serves no constructive purpose. Why is it that we focus more on how terrible divorce is (even in cases where it is a really GOOD thing) than on all the ways single parent families can thrive and succeed? I suspect that our culture (still rampantly patriarchal) is scared by the spectre of women successsfully raising children without the men who have abused, cheated on, and dumped them.