Posted by:
mootman
(
)
Date: April 07, 2013 07:25PM
I had the pleasure of hearing this man speak in a mormon church in Salt Lake City, about the year 2005.
He had the wood box you mention that he claimed the young man Joseph hid the gold plates in. I examined the box up close at his permission after the fireside. I was still a good faithful young man then.
After several years of study and reflection, I know the man is deluded or perpetuating a fraud.
First, he advises the viewer to observe the "grooves" in the box's bottom surface that arose because of supposedly repeated sliding in and out of the spine rings of the plates.
I just sat upon this claim for many years.
Then I began to think: How much would the plates weigh?
This page describes this problem.
http://www.mormonthink.com/runningweb.htmThe plates, according to the best estimation of their dimensions, would have to weigh around 200 pounds.
But as I reflect on the dimensions of this wood box, and the dimensions of the lid opening through which he would have hefted it through repeatedly, countless times to make the supposed grooves-- He would have to be a young man of super human strength. Like, the Hulk. And if he were a Hulk he could not have fit his arms through this small lid opening.
I have done a fair bit of weight lifting as a young man in my 20's; and curling 200 pounds standing or bending over into this box would just simply be impossible. Impossible. Inconceiveable.
Perhaps Joseph had some object that looked like the plates but they could not have been gold plates. Or at least this box Mr. Eldred G. Smith is no evidence of it.