Posted by:
logged out, nli
(
)
Date: September 06, 2018 09:40PM
At last, something concrete. Others have addressed your list, but here's my take (since you were replying to me):
Polygamy: They abandoned it only when faced with an existential crisis. They were willing to die on Polygamy Hill until they figured out that they were actually going to die as an institution and that their god wasn't sending any angels to save them. Hard to give them credit for that one.
Priesthood: They sure did… in 1978, a good 10-20 years into the civil rights movement. Not exactly leading the way there. They caved only when they realized their brand spanking new Brazil temple might sit empty indefinitely because of all the historical intermarriage in that country. Potential embarrassment averted!
Adam-God: So what? That was a Brigham Young pet doctrine. It was abandoned not long after he died, like the Deseret Alphabet, still in the Old Church era.
Eternal Progression: They still teach it, just not publicly. And they lie about teaching it. I don't see that as an improvement.
Blood Oaths: OK, the temple isn't quite as bizarre. But now they won't admit they ever had those, and younger mormons won't believe you when you try to tell them about it. Holland tried to lie his way out of a BBC question about them before being cornered. Again, is official church lying to be considered progress?
Communism vs. Capitalism: The United Order was always doomed to fail. Mormonism has replaced it with an extreme fever-swamp form of capitalism, an alpha-predator version of the prosperity gospel where MLM schemes and financial frauds run wild and free. You may be fine with that, but I'd rather not have the spectacle of average cash-strapped members being used as shark chum.
Contraception: I wouldn't say it’s "A-OK." Sure, the church pays lip service to the wishes of the parents, but when have you ever heard a talk or GC address extolling the virtues of small families? The culture still encourages lots of kids and does its best to achieve that through the usual shame and guilt tactics. Ever been to a Mother's Day sac meeting? Mothers with lots of children are praised and recognized. Meanwhile, women with few or no children are pitied.
Lamanites: Again, not something the church did out of the goodness of their hearts, but because they were forced to do by the mounting multi-disciplinary evidence against the BOM.
Cain: The church continues to lie about this. Their race essay maintains that the priesthood & temple exclusion, and Cain heritage, were merely "theories" although these were in fact referred to at the time as Actual Doctrines Direct From God. As for whether it's taught any more, let me refer you to the *current* BYU Old Testament student manual: "Therefore, although Ham himself had the right to the priesthood, Canaan, his son, did not. Ham had married Egyptus, a descendant of Cain (Abraham 1:21–24), and so his sons were denied the priesthood."
https://www.lds.org/manual/old-testament-student-manual-genesis-2-samuel/genesis-4-11-the-patriarchs?lang=engDiversity: Oh goody, a church-broke South American and a church-broke Asian are in the Q12 now. Color me unimpressed.
Women: I'll give you that. Men will now allow women to speak in situations where they couldn't speak before. But the men still won't listen.
Can you now please address some of the issues raised here that make the New Church as bad or worse than the Old Church?
– The November 2015 exclusion policy
– Every Member a Janitor (despite a $32 billion stock portfolio)
– Obsession with "modesty" and forcing women to be responsible for men’s thoughts
– The masturbation interviews (as has been pointed out to you, they have not been discontinued, and even now the church is preparing to excomm the man who set the "Protect LDS Children" wheels in motion).
– Protecting an MTC president who had a rape room at the MTC, keeping him as a member in good standing, and throwing his rape victim out of the building when she attempted to speak at his ward's F&T meeting
So much empathy!