Posted by:
cricket
(
)
Date: November 21, 2010 05:14AM
First is my review of the book followed by the actual review on the Harvard website. It merely replaced a few words for effect.
Manipulative Mormons takes us into Nauvoo, Illinois teeming with unseemly drama, where since 1840 patriarchologists Susan Perry and Joseph H. Manson have followed the lives of four generations of Mormons. What the authors describe is behavior as entertaining--and occasionally as alarming--as it is recognizable: the competition and cooperation, the jockeying for position and status, the peaceful years under an alpha male devolving into bloody chaos, and the complex traditions passed from one generation to the next. Interspersed with their observations of the Mormons’ lives are the authors’ colorful tales of the challenges of frontier fieldwork--a mixture so rich that by the book’s end we know what it is to be a wild fundamentalist Mormon or a field primatologist. And we are left with a clear sense of the importance of these aggrandized Mormons for understanding human behavioral evolution.
http://www.hup.harvard.edu/catalog.php?recid=31188Manipulative Monkeys takes us into a Costa Rican forest teeming with simian drama, where since 1990 primatologists Susan Perry and Joseph H. Manson have followed the lives of four generations of capuchins. What the authors describe is behavior as entertaining--and occasionally as alarming--as it is recognizable: the competition and cooperation, the jockeying for position and status, the peaceful years under an alpha male devolving into bloody chaos, and the complex traditions passed from one generation to the next. Interspersed with their observations of the monkeys’ lives are the authors’ colorful tales of the challenges of tropical fieldwork--a mixture so rich that by the book’s end we know what it is to be a wild capuchin monkey or a field primatologist. And we are left with a clear sense of the importance of these endangered monkeys for understanding human behavioral evolution.