Posted by:
sophia
(
)
Date: October 09, 2012 11:29PM
My daughter is in her mid-thirties now. She had reflux and a kidney infection.
Here is what the doctor told me back then: They could repair the problem surgically, but if they did nothing she would probably outgrow it. The doctor gave us the choice of surgery or prophylactic antibiotics to prevent infection. We chose daily antibiotics. She had no more infections, and she did outgrow the reflux problem.
In making the decision about what to do, I asked if there were any problems with keeping her on antibiotics long-term. The doctor said the only problem would be that she might become allergic to the antibiotic. This seemed like the more conservative approach, rather than surgery, so that is what we did. IIRC, my daughter was on daily antibiotics for about 3 years.
BUT, and this is HUGE BUT--back then nobody was really attuned to the important role that gut bacteria play in health. It is now understood that gut bacteria are critical to maintaining or breaching the integrity of the gut lining. Good gut bacteria help us properly digest our food, produce healthy brain chemicals, and keep the gut lining intact--permeable enough to allow nutrients to cross it, but with tight enough cell junctions to keep undigested food particles from crossing into the blood stream.
Antibiotics can wipe out healthy bacteria and allow candida to thrive. Over time, candida and other unhealthy organism can compromise the gut lining, leading to autoimmune disorders.
My daughter has celiac disease now, and I am virtually certain that those daily antibiotics when she was young set in motion the cascade of events that eventually led to the celiac disease. (Celiac disease is an autoimmune disease cause by intolerance to gluten in wheat and related grains. The gliadin molecule in gluten should be too large to cross the intestinal barrier of an intact intestine.)
While I agree with Nightingale that you should talk with your doctor about things you give to your young daughter, I was very glad to read that you had thought about giving her probiotics while she is on antibiotics. Cranberries seem to help keep bacteria from sticking to the walls of the bladder, but cranberry "cocktail" that you get in the grocery store is full of sugar and probably won't help. If you use full-strength cranberry juice, it tastes sour. Also, it can acidify the urine, and I would have concerns about the effect of acid on a young child's urinary tract, so talking to the doctor about it would definitely be a good idea.
As for pain, I have had bladder infections and agree that they are painful, but when my daughter was little and had kidney infections, she did not seem to have pain, either in her bladder or her kidneys.
It has been more than 30 years since I dealt with my daughter's reflux and infections. Given the choices I had then, and the knowledge I have now, I think I would choose surgery over long-term antibiotics, but you might have better options now than I did back then.
If long-term antibiotic use is recommended, please do some research on the problem of "leaky gut." Here is a reasonably good overview:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leaky_gutThe science on gut bacteria and gut permeability is pretty young, with much of the research having been done within the last decade.
I don't know what you should do, but plainly this is a treatable condition. Best wishes to you and to her.