Posted by:
spwdone
(
)
Date: March 20, 2013 11:51PM
Wow, Tupperware, I had a similar experience one of the times I was in YW. I was the 1st counselor and actually got in a major argument with the YW & YM pres and the Bishop about it. We had all this stuff, including a tree, to give this less active hispanic family (who had NOT asked for help, btw). They wanted to have this huge group of YW and YM show up to give it to the family.
I was desperate and pulled out scriptures about how you should give without expectation of rewards, etc. I argued until I was blue in the face that if we had to take the stuff we should just leave everything on the porch, ring the doorbell and run, because I thought it was a really, really bad idea. The YW, YM pres & Bishop were positive this was going to be a great spiritual experience for the youth and for the family. It seemed to me that because the family was Hispanic, the YW, YM pres & Bish were sure they were desitute and needed charity. Nothing I said coud convince them otherwise.
It wasn't. The house was kind of small, but nice and well kept. They had normal furniture, everything was very nice. The family was obviously horrified when we showed up. There was a Grandmother and the Mom there and although they were polite, it was obvious they were mortified. They already had a tree. Decorated, with presents.
Only two of the family kids (probably about 10 - 11) were there and they were obviously mortified that we were there as well. You could tell is was taking every ounce of self control and fear of getting in trouble later to keep them from slinking away in embarrassment.
I apologized to the Mom while we were there for just showing up and treating them like charity cases. She and her mother and her children were obviously insulted and nonplussed, they just didn't quite know how to respond. I didn't either and I was with the offending team. I felt so horrible and just didn't know what to do.
The Mom I talked to was very nice about it, although obviously just hoping we would leave soon. I didn't know what to do other than try to hurry things along and apologize profusely for being there.
It was so insulting to them. If people ask for help, that's one thing, but just arbitrarily deciding that you (the ward leadership) think a family isn't living up to their (again, the ward leaderships') standards and that they deserve charity? Totally insulting, especially if they don't even know the people or anything about their lives!
The damn TSCC group stayed forever, even though there were far too many people for a relatively small living room and it was very obvious the family wanted us to leave but were too polite to say so. Then, the YW president INSISTED on setting up the tree the church group had brought, which was bigger, instead of the one the family already had up AND DECORATED.
That involved moving all their presents out of the way, taking ornaments and lights off and taking down their tree before putting the new one up. Without re-doing all the lights and ornaments, of course. Make more work for them, it's a charitable cause.
It was so clear that the Mom and Grandmother and kids were upset about it and too polite to say anything. I have rarely felt more horrible about a situation I was in. It was awful, one of my very worst experiences in TSCC ever and it still burns in my memory.
I felt at the time how wrong it was but other than apologizing and refusing to participate, I just didn't know what else to do. Now, I look back and think at least I could have called and warned them, maybe they could have refused to open the door!
This family never, ever again showed up at church and I was relieved of my calling shortly thereafter (I hit it off with the YW really well and when I asked why I was being released I was told that there were "leadership issues." Basically, the YW pres & I were polar opposites.
I thought the YW pres was an incredibly insensitive bitch, basically - which she was, couldn't stand the woman, especially after the above experience and didn't hide it very well. Shortly afterwards I was put in the RS presidency. Oh, the good times.