Since I seem to disagree with most of the posters, I'm following up with my comment after the thread closed.
http://exmormon.org/phorum/read.php?2,1073983One of the problems people have when they realize the church is bogus and exploitive is making decisions. It is hard to tell what is cult thinking and what is courageous, normal thinking.
As you ponder the different choices, do not be hasty. Give your subconscious mind time to ponder the various ideas. You will be amazed to experience the cloudy water clearing and the right path becoming more and more obvious.
Only you can determine the "right" path for you because, like with most decisions, there is no arbitrary right or wrong--it's what is right or wrong FOR YOU at your present stage in life.
To help you make this decision, establish your priorities. You have indicated that your physical problems are more significant than the mental ones because you think the mental ones are temporary.
Many young men do not realize how significant their mental state is. Your mental state is ALWAYS number one, whether you are a missionary or an apostate, whether you are young/old, in a foreign country, employed/unemployed, no matter WHAT.
The reason is that without a healthy mental state, you might not even seek medical help for a possibly fatal physical condition. You might attribute stomach pains to stress and blame yourself, for not handling your stress better, when in fact, you may have a parasitic infection.
I have seen this with my own eyes.
So if we can agree that your mental state comes first, the next fact to consider is that you have been asking to go home for nine long months. This shows you that those who are responsible for your welfare are not interested in your welfare. It also shows you that you are not a volunteer. You are a social hostage with your status as a respected male member of your tribe being used to hold you and compel your participation.
Without anger, these are the facts of your situation.
When you look at your situation with clear eyes, you realize that you ANd ONLY YOU have your back when it comes to your personal happiness. Your MP doesn't care if you are happy or not, neither do your parents. Sorry if this is hurtful, but a further manipulation added to you is the humiliation your parents must endure if they fail to deliver to the cult a submissive church-broken son which they can milk and use.
Forgive my being blunt. I'm the exmormon grandmother you don't have-- and sorely need.
Back to your situation - you have been under duress for at least the last nine months asking for relief. This is stress you have been carrying and it has been increasing as the burden of cognitive dissonance increases in your mind. For all of us, the recognition that our "rod of iron" is in actuality a noodle of lies is a horrifying realization. People faint, throw up, develop ulcers, colitis, and have mental crises over just learning that Joseph Smith was a con man.
I am laying out the stress factors because it us UP TO YOU to manage your mental state by limiting the stress factors and scheduling more relaxing and sleeping time. The missionary experience is designed to break a person's autonomy, show them that they are weak and need superior others to be acceptable to God and their society. They break you and replace your confidence in your own judgment with magical thinking and dependence on knowledgable elders--themselves. It's a cultural process we see in other (primitive) societies.
They want your time, your money, your will. If you don't give it to them, they will take away the people you love and all hope of having respect in Mormon society.
Placed on the horns of this dilemma is often so uncomfortable that people just say F--it and become tithepaying non-believers "out of love."
There is no love before self-love. You must love and respect yourself FIRST before you can extend true compassion and love to others, even your family, even your girlfriend. This is why they say "To your self be true." Integrity and self-worth comes from the calm confidence of doing what YOU think is right, leading your life authentically, having your actions match YOUR values.
In consideration of all of the above, I encourage you to seek a break for yourself. Give yourself some time to take a deep breath, get some rest, get your bearings, choose wisely and think deeply under a tree by a stream.
There is no hurry. You are young. You will realize that you cannot complete a mission "with honor" because those who run the mission have no honor. They have none to give you and the status they offer IS PHONY! It would be based on you pretending to be something you are not, which is what they do every day of their lives.
You admire your mission president? How about the possibility that he is smart and knows it is not true but doesn't mind leading happy families away from the focus they now have on their own needs and setting them up to believe they must give your organization 10% of their income and an unspecified amount of their time ---ALL TAKEN FROM THEIR CHILDREN-- who actually have a right to their parents' attention and support.
It is not ok to take a message to people that they will lose their families after they die UNLESS they act now... but you already know all this.
I have a mentally ill son with a lifelong disablity. He had a breakdown, like many missionaries have had. They went home in a strait jacket, my son went to a construction lot and carved up his limbs with a linoleum knife. He was under too much stress and pressure, had been shot in a holdup, was abandoned by his adopted father and felt like a man would not call his mommy for help. He will never have a career or a family and a good day is one where the voices are not too bothersome.
You can push yourself too hard, stay too long, put up with too much.
When my son feels overwhelmed with anxiety, he takes a "respite." This means he goes someplace else for a couple of weeks and talks to counselors, walks in nature, swims, etc. Things he doesn't normally get to do.
I suggest you put everything aside and take a break. Your writing speaks volumes about where you want to be -- you want the comfort and solace you feel at your girlfriends house, there with her family. Don't listen to people who call you a coward. That is the mindset of those who grew up in this horrible cult of Mormonism and view the missionary experience as a rite of passage.
You are free to reject the notion that you have anything to prove to anyone regarding your manhood. No one has to walk in your shoes and feel what you do in your mind, only YOU will live with the consequences of placing your exhausted self in a healing environment or going back to the states to your parent's basement or your childhood room.
In my view, that would be very stressful because you will be viewed with suspicion and forced to "Prove" your Mormonosity. You will have to double down, carry oil, take three callings, wear two pair of garments...you get my drift.
I suggest healing this trauma away from your family rather than adding to the trauma by proving to the ward that you are worthy even though returning early.
Either way, you can certainly take some time.
Best
Anagrammy