Posted by:
MJ
(
)
Date: March 31, 2011 07:31PM
It is, of course nonsense.
In thread:
http://exmormon.org/phorum/read.php?2,152065,153383#msg-153383Gullible's Travel's tries to make the case that because the relatively simple snowflake can be duplicated by there relatively simple creation processes that this somehow applies to the process of creating a human soul.
Disparaging the ad hominems in his post, we are left with the idea that simply because a snowflake and a human are complex things then we can justifiable make assumptions about the likelihood of any specific snowflake and any particular human being identical.
In order for his assertions to be true, the processes of making each must be the same, if the process differ, there is no guarantee the results would be the same.
It seems simple to me that looking at an inanimate object and using its characteristics to make claims about a living being is an inappropriate thing to do, but it does not seem to be such a simple concept for Gullible's Travel's.
A snowflake is created via the laws of physics, that's it folks, that covers the process of creating a snowflake.
The creation of humanity and and individual humans is not limited to the laws of physics. Evolution and natural selection are forces that apply to humans but NOT TO SNOWFLAKES. Reproduction via sex is something that applies to humans BUT NOT TO SNOWFLAKES. Natural selection, sex, and by extension sexual attractions are not generally considered part of the laws of physics.
Evolution and sexual attractions are also NOT random, so the principal of randomness that Gullible's Travel's relies on do not apply.
Sorry, Gully, but YOUR POINT SIMPLY IS NOT VALID and all you adhominims will not change that.
The snowfalke formation is governed by physics, the creation of the self IS NOT. The rules of physics that you require for your point to be valid SIMPLY DO NOT APPLY TO HUMANS AND THE CREATION OF OTHER HUMANS.
The rules for creating a snowflake and the rules for creating humans are different.
Edited 3 time(s). Last edit at 03/31/2011 07:44PM by MJ.