Priorities people! It doesn't matter whether or not the cupcake was willingly licked. Licked cupcakes can't just roam around campus where they may do harm to those who only want to lick un-licked cupcakes.
"Sometimes, though, “facts come to light that a victim has engaged in prior Honor Code violations,” she said, adding that those facts can be investigated." -- Carrie Jenkins
Notice the word "can". Not "should" or "will". That word conveys a vindictive attitude. You get yourself raped, we'll dig up dirt on you just because we can.