Posted by:
Cold-Dodger
(
)
Date: March 16, 2022 12:03AM
I can’t be the only one who has suffered rifts in their family over politics in the last five years. The reason I agitated the mods of this board to accept some political discourse here was because I was being outmanned and outgunned at the dinner table and since everybody knows I’m an atheist, they already don’t grant me the slightest amount of assumed dignity about my intentions, morality, or intelligence. What made it difficult, however, is that when I would repeat something I had heard from CNN, I had an army of conservatives pull out it their phones with memes and clips and articles ready to go for exactly a moment like this: an opportunity to put a militant liberal atheist in his place.
I did not leave the church because I wanted to play for the “other team” anymore than I backed the church because I considered it my tribe. Something in my head does not register the world tribally that way the way other people seem to. I’m not claiming to magically free of all all bias and human emotions. But my natural cognition leans heavily towards objectivity; otherwise, I get pretty anxious. I think other people hide behind from their feelings by melding into the perceived group consensus. I can’t do that. I wish I could sometimes. If I could, I would be just like everyone else. Maybe I’d still be Mormon and indistinguishable from any one of my heteronormative tbm brothers. But I’m not. I’m a thinker. Not an overthinker: I have to think just to make out social details about another person that most other people can infer from a glance or gather with much less thinking. As a BIC, this quality of mine was destined to screw me over.
Mormon testimonies are nothing but conviction that our professed tribal morality, or ideals that set our tribe apart, will have to be good enough, because if we don’t like it, we can go it alone in a hostile world that we have been conditioned to think is more hostile than it really is, a world they haven’t lifted a finger to give us any skills to live in autonomously — only as borg drones for the hive. Give God all the glory —- and since rituals are how we come to him, and since rituals have to be authorized to be considered valid, and since that authority can only be found in this church, what this means is stay in the church, do whatever it says to do, and induct other people into it and strengthen your own brainwashing as often as you can. Anything less to Mormon thought is not giving God the glory. Current events in the world are to be thought of as God attempting to open up mission fields with wheat ripe ready to harvest, and constitutional rights and domestic issues are to be thought of as events that either maximize or encroach on our rights to be Mormon, our rights to persuade other people to be Mormon, and the church’s rights as a legal incorporated religious entity to be exempt from taxes, hoard food and ammo, and buy obscene amounts of real estate because they’re sticking it to the Gentiles for Missouri and the blood of the prophets or something.
The church and all doomsday prepper religions have biases about the world that, as far as I can tell, make them prime mental real estate for Christian nationalism (“this country was founded on judeo-Christian values”), to a lesser extent white nationalism (“we didn’t sign up for THIS amount of immigration”), and — to make it a three-pair — some amount of Deseret nationalism. Deseret being the name of the single unified proposed state that the Mormons wanted their occupied territories to be called when the Union reabsorbed the Utah and surrounding terrorizes from the Mexican American war. People think DesNat is simply the Mormon alt-right, but technically any Mormon who sees inside the church a political organization that would outlast the downfall of the federal government and eventually rise to become the government of a Mormon-dominated state is a Deseret nationalist. Just the preppers who indulge in the insane corners of the internet to nurse how ostracized they feel in real life are the lonely isolated losers who get called DesNat extremists. Everybody else in the church is happy to kick the blossoming of the church into an actual government on earth, aka the kingdom or God or modern Israel, back to sometime just before the second coming or not until afterwards — which is soon, they hope, but the difference is that they’re not trolling online spaces threatening people who live in the vicinity of Mormons. The church leaves open the door to this stuff though. There would be no DesNat, no polygamists in Utah, and no Bundy family trying to start shit with the Fed in the name of God and country if there was no Mormon church.
Ah, but me wishing for a world in which the church never existed will sound to some ears like I’m wishing it would go away by some means or another. It will sound to those ears like I’m just a different kind of zealot, a godless kind, which “militant atheist” is meant to convey. It will sound to them like I have an agenda, an liberal agenda, to destroy their religious liberties. And since the CIA has done such a good job wrapping capitalism in the trappings of democracy and freedom — the American flag — and in turn wrapping those values up in the religion of Jesus Christ, it’s a skip hop and jump for these folks to assume my militant liberal atheist agenda is a communist one too. I know how this works, because I did not always take positions I now hold. I started on the other side and worked my way into my current persuasions just out of curiosity to be exposed to new ideas and hold on to them if they made sense.
I must seem an odd caricature of an anti-Mormon to some of these eyes, but my first ideas about who “they” are who always trying to get us — those nameless faceless godless commie liberal anti-Mormon anti-American bastards (as though it was the same homogenous group of people and ideas) that the scriptures and the Q15 every six months warned me about and whom my elders talked about for some amount of time at the dinner table every night especially since Obama got elected the first time. Well, when you get into politics, “they” suddenly have a face — Ben Shapiro explains it every night. Glenn Beck. Rush Limbaugh. Michael Savage. Alex Jones for some. Now Q-anon. These are great men, from a particular prepperism-tainted-by-cold-war-propaganda point of view, who tell you about the troop movements of the commies, the force deployment of the armies of Satan, and any significant develops in the liberal agenda which is a war on true worship, modes of family conducive of childhood indoctrination of true worship. Recently the liberal agenda was slowly phased out for the “gay agenda” besides the original liberal agenda and finally the “LGBT agenda and the BLM agenda” or simply the “commie agenda”.
When I “durst” to lift up my head and question whether my shame, my anxiety, my curiosity-repression and the accompanying depression. were just the symptoms of a lie invented by men and meant to control me, it was very much in the language of Korihor, for behold these the were the words I was originally given and up to that point they were only words I had for such things. And, yes, these words had been deliberately chosen or redefined to discourage or even make impossible to conceive of rebellion against the church and actually carrying out such rebellion. But I would not be bounded by that. I don’t like boundaries on my mind and tolerated them up to the age of 25 simply because that is how terrified of being abandoned that I felt. But by then I was low-key cool with it; I even expected it. I knew nobody was ever going to talk to me again the instant I admitted I had “fallen”. What I never expected though is that they would vote for an open demagogue right after this happened and that I would regret losing the favored position I had once had in their hearts. There was a time when I had the ears of many people through my parents, but the thing was that I wasn’t happy and I was dying inside keeping those connections open and minds losing them anyway the more I aged and still wasn’t married. 25 is the limit on which they will allow you to be a bachelor without considering you simply anti-social in the menace to society sense. You need not do anything except not have a ring on your finger by this age to garner this ire in some Mormon families.
I couldn’t talk them out of it. I couldn’t convince them he was a liar until it was too late. I couldn’t convince them that was forever altering political norms that ought not to be altered until it was too late.. They countered me often, to my surprise, with facts and information about the people on “my side” (and the ‘liberal media’ also counts as part of ‘my side’) that were not defensible. The facts are, it seems, that we live in a time of extreme corruption (or things which ought to be illegal even if they aren’t) that made my glad tidings of great joy that the liberal secular world is not what they thought fall on deaf ears. Not only deaf ears, but ears which were trained — willfully trained — to recognize key phrases in any liberal’s political pitch as an admission of guilt of the entire liberal agenda that what some libs dubbed “hate radio” had been earning them about for thirty years and more. I just didn’t want them to, on the eve of my escape from Mormonism, take the secular world away from me too, which I was just starting to like.
Everything on my father’s side of the table is all part of a bigger truth: the fact that the church is true and that I am damned if I will have none of it. These are facts in that house. They demand that it be treated as an uncontroversial, incontrovertible given, something manifest by reality itself through the senses, even if they in the next breath knock ”the critics” (said with contempt in a particular way every time the word is used this way) for seeking signs and tempting God and wanting to know things through their physical senses for themselves. Some realities are even realer than the definition of “real” to them, and their eagerness to make this feel true to protect all the feelings they’ve heretofore invested in this hill is why they voted for that man. It’s also why they seemingly believe anything as long it doesn’t require them to regret anything else they’ve done before in the service of God and country as long its king is Jesus.
They’re only allowed to regret not knowing the will of God more perfectly than they did before, which is why we’re having limited success convincing them to tolerate gay people but only up to a point and with stipulations. Just forget about the trans thing. That’s a redline and I’ve never met anybody from my old life who even paused before they said “no” to whatever they thought I was about to say in defense of trans rights. That’s a shame, because I have a whole sleuth of arguments I’ve come up with on my own that the trans lifestyle is just as choiceless as the gay issue and that how someone identifies, talks, dresses, and even modifies their bodies is no different from the rights Mormons defend every day when as long as they are traditional religious practices that have been around a while. What’s the difference between a Mormon and a trans person? They’re both born in an awful situation of fog it really dissonance in the which their curiosity which could save them is forbidden under threat of becoming a social pariah. They both feel like outcasts that society loves to hate. They both have their own unique views about themselves that not everybody is cool with. They dress differently, even wearing underwear they’re not “supposed” to wear, and they modify their bodies because, idk, it’s what society expects them to do. My parents chopped part of my dick off when I was a baby and didn’t think anything of it, because it’s just normal. It’s fascinating to me how they refuse to think about that or just regurgitate some crap to me about how it’s cleaner or doesn’t hurt anything, but then spend all this energy refuting every single talking point a liberal has to make about why people should get vaccinated. They fancy themselves independent thinkers on very narrow subjects. Vaccination is the only issue I’ve ever heard my father disagree with the prophet on. Muttering something about globalists and George Soros in reference to the president of the church was… different. In the same light, many conservative congressmen are being disowned and pushed away. My parents even decided that Fox News had sold out when they called Arizona for the liberals and then tried to call a spade a spade on January 6th. They feel so entitled to having their feelings comforted and their god-fearing egos stroked, they don’t know how to exist in a world where the kids don’t want those old time values and vote for a socialist instead.
They don’t understand, and it’s not because I’m not there begging them to let me explain it to them. I am there. I was there with my arm stretched out for far longer than I was obligated to be. I’m text, nobody even wanted to dignify my pose with any kind of acknowledgment. I was there, the same bright kid they used to know only become a man and using his gifts to learn how to live in the world they swore to hate the same way I used to use my gifts to defend the church and articulate the gospel to people. I was there. I didn’t know everything, but I knew a new way of thinking that I felt unlocked my potential and a gift for articulation. I was there for them in the long-suffering example I learned from many lessons about being like Jesus, offering to use my gifts to ease them into an evidence- seed worldview even just a little so they didn’t vote for fascism because in their ignorance it was all they could think to do, and they all but spit on me and cussed me out for it. I waited until I reached my limit. After their guy was gone out of office, I blew up on them in ways I regret — not for what I said, but the rude and bridge-burning way that I said it. But I’d had enough of being lectured about respecting other people’s feelings when they never respected mine nor recognized what me respecting their feelings look like until one day I didn’t care anymore.
I don’t know if things could have worked out some other way. I have had to invent an approach, because these things get talked about in my parent’s house, and unchallenged as they go they’re almost taken as part of their religion or something. Winning an argument is not important to me. If I’m wrong, I’m wrong. I wanna show them how to think, how to reason, how to tell what is true through falsification and skepticism. That is the hill that I’ve been dying in for a long time. But I’m tired. I’m so tired of feeling alone. I’m so tired of feeling like the people who they love me the most are doing everything in their power to make sure I can’t be happy if it isn’t in the way they prescribed. I’m tired of not having every good opinion and every ally I should have had in order to defend very basic questions like what a society without god is going to be like. I have no idea, honestly. I just thought if more people accepted a science-based worldview, we could be more constructive with our democracy or something. My family are convinced that they’ve seen a glimpse of what is to come through the liberal agenda and the None movement and they’re having none of it, by which I mean they intend to destroy it with their vote and then shoot at it after that fails. They will have their way. God, the most odious dictator there ever was and the hardest regime to depose, is on their side, they think, and like any totalitarian regime they dare not question his will and all will be made to bend to the knee and confess that his ways are just. Truly did the words of Christopher Hitchens speak to me that wishing for a celestial North Korea situation is the saddest thing a civicly-literate man of culture can witness. Talk about ceaseless praises. Talk about Big Brother. Talk about anxiety. I know that anxiety, and I pity them still and wish better for them, but they don’t want to be saved and they look upon me in much the same way.