Posted by:
3X
(
)
Date: January 08, 2011 04:37PM
http://community.nytimes.com/comments/www.nytimes.com/2011/01/09/fashion/09Modern.html?sort=oldest&offset=2Poster "Tom" SoCal January 8th, 2011 3:05
<quote>
Well written and intense. And sad. The Mormon church produces a lot of sadness and depression, not just in women, but men as well. The expectations are so high, and the competitive ritualization of the lifestyle can consume one's soul. This story reminds me of Terry Tempest William's "Refuge". A woman looking for meaning and self-importance after the rigor of being told by the Mormon corporation that you are not meeting their standards. So 19th century. The Mormon church fought tooth and nail to keep women from having the right to vote, or any rights for that matter, and the way are still treated is as possessions and means to an end for men to gain exaltation. My wife recently commented on a book by a Mormon author that she felt his story of self discovery and identification with place seem completely self indulgent and self congratulatory, even gross. But growing up in that culture is difficult, if not smothering, and when one determines to leave the church and take another course, it may take a lifetime of excuses, rationalization and guilt to ever fully divorce one's self from the doctrines so thoroughly instilled. Clearly religion has a place in human existence. Its adherents find community, meaning and fulfillment in the shared experience. But Mormonism is not for the faint of heart. And it may not be right for anyone. How it has managed to spread as it has is beyond me. I struggle to understand how anyone could find meaning its teachings. The shallowness of its doctrine, the overbearing and controlling nature of it ritual, and the adherence to a lifestyle more representative of the 1800s than now seems quaint at best, and tortuous at worst. Every aspect of one's life is controlled, your diet, your clothing choices, your sex life, your weekend and even daily activities, who you marry, who you date, what movies you watch and the music you listen to, and they even know the personal details of your finances. If you don't pay a full tithe, they know it. And by that they know your income. Who wants that? Perhaps in a time when women could not own property and children were needed to run the farm would such archaic ideas be acceptable. But now they do little more than subjugate and control the "group" by limiting their freewill.
So thanks for the great story Nicole. It sounds like so many women I knew growing up, and who still are single. There are many thousands more women just like you out there, even many sad and beaten down Mormon women who have found a husband. Their suffering simply comes in a different form.
<endquote>