Posted by:
Nightingale
(
)
Date: January 04, 2024 07:39PM
I wanted to transcribe this for anyone who can't play it or hear it as I think he said something important. I hope it makes a difference for others in his ward as well.
If I'd heard more talks like this at church I may have stuck longer - very heartfelt, emotional, thought-provoking, honest. I'm so curious to know what happened to bring him to this place but maybe we can give it a good guess, due to our own experiences.
I know I missed a few spots where I couldn't quite hear him as he got emotional and then sniffy with his drippy nose. That demonstrated though how heartfelt his announcement and his feelings were, as did the spots where he spoke so softly - I hope I caught most of his words accurately.
He said (as best I could hear him):
Two and a half years ago when I was called to be bishop President Richardson came to my home and he sat down on the couch with my wife and I and issued the call. When he left the home I was quite emotional but I remember shutting the door behind him and the words from Section 121 came into my mind:
"It is the nature and disposition of almost all men as soon as they get a little authority as they suppose – as they suppose - they begin to exercise unrighteous dominion. And the Spirit said Don’t --- you --- ever --- do it.” And I’ve thought of that and I never have.
I was talking with Brother ______ this morning. (Couldn't hear the next sentence - sounded like ---- Israel) – It is we who wrestle with God. I want to tell you about a wrestle I’ve had. Ernest Hemingway once said the most painful thing is losing yourself in the process of loving something or someone too much and forgetting that you’re special too. I owe it to my ward family to hear it from me. (Starts wiping eyes and nose from tearing up - genuine emotion). I have asked to be released. Not because of some sin. Not because I’m hiding something. Not at all. There are just a few things that I’ve been required to do that I personally cannot morally stand by. I can’t (slowly raises one shoulder). So I need to step down. For me and my family’s well-being. It’s not been easy. But I feel in many ways I’m failing the ward. I know this is hard. I understand. But I have to be true to my feelings (tears up). I have been angry. Every Sunday people look at me and they’re like “Man, Bishop - is something wrong?” I can’t do that to you. I won’t. I won’t do it. Because that turns to anger and bitterness and malevolence.
I’ve written down a few things, if it’s OK if I could just share my thoughts. Sometimes due to church culture we feel like we’re not supposed to turn down or step away from a calling. I wish I had known it was OK to say to myself “I’m not OK. I’m not as strong as I thought I was.” [Not sure this is what he said: To see that it’s important] - That’s my life, to see excellence, more – doing more – being successful. It’s so much more important to know that you’re OK and I haven’t been OK. This calling, guys, it’s so hard. You have to keep everything to yourself. And it builds up and it is exhausting. And it – it has broken me. (Emotional, lots of nose-wiping, near-whisper voice).
I didn’t have good parents. [I can't swear to the accuracy of that sentence - I can't quite believe he would say that right out loud like that - but it seems to fit the context and that is what it sounds like he said.] I wish they would have told me I was enough. They never have. That whether I had worth or not wasn’t contingent on how I acted. We are not loved for what we do or what we are going to do. We are loved for who we are. Not an expectation, but who we are. And to feel love for who you are is the most sacred kind of love. It’s a gift that we have the opportunity to give to ourselves. (Good thing there’s a box of Kleenex on the stand at this point. And I need some of my own too by now).
If I can just say one more thing towards the youth. Because they are the reason I’ve stayed as long as I have. I love them. If there is ever injustice in the world, young men, young women – there’s not many here but listen – if there’s ever injustice in the world - fight it. If there is ever a bully somewhere stand up to it. And if you ever have something to say, say it, just say it. Don’t fear. Get rid of fear. And if you don’t want to do that, that’s OK. You’re still enough. Instead of judgement, choose compassion. Instead of division, see everyone as you living a different life. And remember - people say it like Alma. Remember. Remember. That you’re enough. Everyone else is too. You are redeemed. You are always forgiven no matter what. This was a man who came to know the Christ. Seek Christ. Seek only Christ.
I realize a lot of people are going to have a lot of questions. Join the club. So do we. This has not been easy for my family. It’s not been easy at all. It hasn’t been easy for anybody. And this is not going to continue to be easy (he scrambled these words around – I didn’t edit them). But we want you to know we love you. I told Jeff this morning – I said that if we get called for tornado work he’s still riding shotgun. I’m just not going to wear this (white?? - couldn't hear) shirt. I know Brother Bailey has prepared quite a bit for the next hour so I will sit down. But I want you to know this is very hard for me. I know it’s hard for you. But I know it’s the right thing to do. Someone else who is better suited will do the job.
So with that being said, let’s close out the meeting. It’s kind of ironic – I see it's Hymn #227 - There is Sunshine in My Soul Today (a few soft laughs from the audience). After which we’ll have a benediction and I totally forgot who it was who was supposed to give the prayer – after which Brother Osgood will give the benediction.
-----
Wow. That was courageous of him. First, to realize he had to step down, for reasons he didn't specify here. Also, to want to speak to the congregation and try to let them know first hand what's up.
To me, the crux of his anguish is reflected in these words he spoke that he is honest enough, and heartbroken enough, to want to let his people know:
"There are just a few things that I’ve been required to do that I personally cannot morally stand by. I can’t."
"I have to be true to my feelings. I have been angry."
"I wish I had known it was OK to say to myself “I’m not OK.”
"This calling, guys, it’s so hard. You have to keep everything to yourself. And it builds up and it is exhausting. And it – it has broken me."
"That whether I had worth or not wasn’t contingent on how I acted. We are not loved for what we do or what we are going to do. We are loved for who we are. Not an expectation, but who we are. And to feel love for who you are is the most sacred kind of love. It’s a gift that we have the opportunity to give to ourselves."
"– if there’s ever injustice in the world - fight it. If there is ever a bully somewhere stand up to it. And if you ever have something to say, say it, just say it. Don’t fear. Get rid of fear. And if you don’t want to do that, that’s OK. You’re still enough. Instead of judgement, choose compassion. Instead of division, see everyone as you living a different life."
"Remember. Remember. That you’re enough. Everyone else is too."
-----
Sure, we can speculate. Many here have been where he undoubtedly is. I hope he can take his own words to heart "You are enough". "We are loved for who we are." (Would that were true, especially inside countless church organizations).
I feel for him. I hope so much that he can find those who will understand, and love, and see him as worthwhile just for who he is. And I hope he sees and feels that for his own self as well.
Of course I'm intensely curious about the things he referred to obliquely - no details - but we could give it a good guess. He just couldn't bring himself to bishop the way the church wants its men to bishop. He is full of compassion and honesty and love and who knows what all agonies he's felt due to the obligations he's felt as a Mormon bishop. Perhaps many here can guess what that would be about.
That was a bit of a tearjerker. I am speculating about what could have finally pushed him to this edge. I think this is a most revealing statement, among others above:
"There are just a few things that I’ve been required to do that I personally cannot morally stand by. I can’t."
I hope he doesn't beat himself up too much about his decision to step down. And I hope he keeps on asking questions and thinking things through.
Edited 2 time(s). Last edit at 01/04/2024 07:49PM by Nightingale.